Skip to the labels
Messengerupdate

NHL Games & Standings

Oilers' Second Pair Isn't Scoring, But Is It a Trade Problem?

NHL Trade Talk 777 reads

Connor Murphy and Ryan Shea keep goals out but generate almost nothing at the other end. The real question is whether Edmonton's top-heavy forward group is the bigger issue.

Oilers' Second Pair Isn't Scoring, But Is It a Trade Problem?

Edmonton's 13-3-3 start has most of the attention on Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, which is fair. Still, the Oilers' second pair of Murphy and Shea has become the quiet debate of the early season. Allan Mitchell of The Athletic asked whether Edmonton needs to trade for an upgrade on the second pair, and he suggested that if the club wants a Stanley Cup, Murphy and Shea must play better. He also floated the idea that general manager Stan Bowman may already be eyeing a move that would slide Murphy down to the third pair.

Here's the thing: that's a reasonable question, but the answer depends on where the blame really sits.

A Pair That Defends but Doesn't Drive Play

Mitchell's core point is that the pair doesn't score and isn't winning its minutes. Some observers have said Murphy looks slower and struggles to move the puck. Those are fair observations, and they deserve a hearing. But they don't tell the whole story.

A separate Athletic piece on players who need to step up across the league singled out Murphy as the Oilers' most concerning regular. That writer pointed to a 35 percent xG rate and described Murphy as a "complete black hole offensively." The same piece added that his defensive game hasn't been pretty either. That's a harsh line, and it's worth noting that Murphy has never been a point producer. The problem is that the defensive side isn't covering for the offensive gap.

Shea and Murphy also aren't getting help from the forwards in front of them. Ice time matters here. Bouchard and Ekholm play most of their minutes with McDavid and Draisaitl, which leaves the second pair with whatever's left. Any pair in that spot is going to look thin on offense, and that's basically arithmetic, not a judgment on either defenceman.

Where the Chances Are Coming From

The Oilers' forwards run from elite at the top to much less reliable further down. Any line featuring McDavid or Draisaitl is among the best in the league. Rookie Owen Michaels has been the weakest option this season. He started well but has struggled in recent weeks. A defence pair is only as good as the forwards it plays with, and Shea and Murphy have had little to work with.

The five-on-five splits are where this gets interesting. With McDavid on the ice, the pair has played 27 minutes together, and that group has scored as many goals as it has allowed. The shot quality against them, though, points to a lower number of expected goals against than they actually gave up. That could easily be bad luck over a small sample.

Connor Murphy Edmonton Oilers defenseman
Connor Murphy Edmonton Oilers defenseman

With Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, the pair logged 62 minutes. That trio hasn't scored, but it has allowed 1.92 goals per 60 minutes, which is better than the 2.36 expected. Alongside Jason Dickinson over 34 minutes, the numbers look similar: 1.84 goals against per 60 and no goals for. With the Michaels line over 83 minutes, the pair allowed 2.16 per 60 against an expected 2.82. The Oilers scored 40 percent of the goals in those minutes, well above the 20 percent expected, but only because that line creates so little in the first place.

The pattern is clear. Shea and Murphy prevent goals against. What's missing is anyone finishing at the other end, and finishing isn't the defencemen's job. This pair is built to defend, with Shea as the more active passer and Murphy as the low-offence partner. The open question is whether that role is good enough once the schedule gets tougher.

The Options If the Offence Never Arrives

Jake Walman was expected to be a difference-maker on the second pair and hasn't been. That changes the conversation. If the pair never adds offence, Edmonton has a few paths.

The first is the simplest: get Walman back to form so his offence helps the cause. The second is internal. Ty Emberson and Shakir Mukhamadullin are both options to move up from the organization's depth. The third is a trade, which is where the debate tends to end up.

Murphy's skating and puck movement are legitimate concerns, especially with the playoffs in mind. His contract could also become harder to live with as he ages, which is one reason some fans want the club to act before that becomes a bigger problem. That said, a trade for a defenceman doesn't automatically add the kind of finishing the Oilers lack.

Mitchell's view is that the better question right now is what happens once Matt Savoie is back and Zach Hyman is fully up to speed. A stronger supporting cast would show quickly whether Shea and Murphy can drive results or simply hold the fort. If it turns out they're holding the fort, the fix sits up front, not on the blue line.

My Read

For now, the second pair is doing its job defensively, and that's worth something on a team with this much firepower. The bigger issue is the second line. Edmonton needs more goals from its second group of forwards, and the second pair's offensive limits are a symptom of that gap more than a cause.

I'd hold off on a deal for a defenceman until the forwards around the back end get healthier and the lineup settles. If Shea and Murphy are still just holding the line in a few weeks, that's when the trade talk gets serious.

Source: NHL Trade Talk · nhltradetalk.com

Same drawer