Skip to the labels
Messengerupdate

NHL Games & Standings

Could Sidney Crosby Fit the Oilers? A Proposed Trade and the Obstacles

Vivek Kalia 844 reads

A hypothetical Crosby deal would give Edmonton another elite centre, but Pittsburgh’s captain would need to approve a move and the Oilers would need cap space.

Could Sidney Crosby Fit the Oilers? A Proposed Trade and the Obstacles

The proposed Sidney Crosby deal would give the Edmonton Oilers a third elite centre for a team already built around Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. It’s a compelling win-now idea, but the path from proposal to reality runs through Crosby’s decision and Edmonton’s salary-cap math.

Edmonton’s 17-3-3 record frames the appeal: the Oilers are already serious contenders, and Crosby could add scoring depth, defensive awareness, faceoff strength and championship experience. Pittsburgh, meanwhile, is 7-11-2, prompting renewed questions about whether its direction could eventually affect the future of its longtime captain. That context makes a hypothetical trade worth examining, though it doesn’t establish that Crosby wants to leave.

The proposed trade package

The proposal sends Crosby to Edmonton with Pittsburgh retaining $3 million of his $8.7 million salary-cap hit. That would leave the Oilers with a $5.7 million cap hit for Crosby for the remainder of the season.

  • Edmonton receives: Sidney Crosby, with Pittsburgh retaining $3 million.
  • Pittsburgh receives: Isaac Howard, Matthew Savoie, Beau Akey, a 2028 first-round pick and a 2027 second-round pick.
Sidney Crosby Oilers Penguins

Even with Pittsburgh retaining salary, Edmonton would need to find room for Crosby’s remaining cap hit. The proposed route could involve a separate move, potentially one involving Jake Walman. That would add another transaction to a deal already requiring the Oilers to part with two prospects, a young defenceman and two picks.

What Edmonton would be buying

Three top centres would give Edmonton a rare set of options down the middle. Opponents would have to manage McDavid and Draisaitl while accounting for Crosby, and the Oilers could use his defensive detail and faceoff ability in situations where a dependable centre matters as much as another scoring threat.

Crosby’s experience in long playoff runs is another part of the case. Edmonton’s goal would be to turn its current contention into a Stanley Cup, and adding a three-time champion would bring a proven player into that push. A line-up featuring Crosby, McDavid and Draisaitl would also draw enormous attention, but the hockey value would depend on how the coaches deployed them and how the rest of the roster fit around their cap hits.

The cost is substantial. Savoie and Howard are both presented as important pieces of Edmonton’s future, while Akey adds a right-shot defensive prospect to Pittsburgh’s return. Sending out that group plus two draft picks would leave the Oilers with less prospect depth. For a team trying to win now, the calculation is whether Crosby’s contribution over the remainder of the season is worth that long-term cost.

Pittsburgh’s decision and Crosby’s say

For the Penguins, the package would offer several paths to replenish their pipeline. Savoie would be the centrepiece, with top-six potential; Howard would add offensive upside; and Akey would give Pittsburgh a promising right-shot defenceman. The picks could add further options as the team builds for the future.

But the package only matters if Crosby is willing to go. He has a full no-movement clause and would need to approve any trade. While he has spoken about his loyalty to Pittsburgh, he has also acknowledged that “anything can happen” in hockey. Those comments leave room for uncertainty; they don’t amount to a request to be moved.

Josh Yohe: Most people I’ve spoken to within the organization believe Sidney Crosby will return to Pittsburgh next season, but no one truly knows because Crosby doesn’t seem to know what he wants to do – The Athletic (11/16)

— NHL Rumour Report (@NHLRumourReport) November 17, 2026

Josh Yohe’s reporting says Pittsburgh would accommodate Crosby if he asked to leave, while also conveying uncertainty about what Crosby wants. A chance to chase another championship alongside McDavid and Draisaitl could be appealing, but there’s no indication he has requested a move. Any discussion of Edmonton remains hypothetical unless he chooses to waive his protection.

Precedent and the practical hurdles

Late-career moves by prominent players show how a player’s preference can shape a trade. In 2022, Philadelphia sent Claude Giroux to Florida in a package featuring Owen Tippett, a first-round pick and a third-round pick. The following year, Patrick Kane waived his no-movement clause to join the New York Rangers, with Chicago receiving draft picks and a depth defenceman.

Those trades offer reference points, not a fixed price for Crosby. His championship record, leadership and continued impact could make his return especially difficult to match, while his no-movement clause gives him control over whether a deal can proceed at all.

For Edmonton, the next questions are concrete: can it clear enough cap space, and would Crosby approve a move? The proposed package shows the scale of assets the Oilers might have to consider. Until both obstacles are addressed, the idea is an ambitious fit for Edmonton’s championship window, not evidence of an imminent trade.

Source: Vivek Kalia · nhltradetalk.com

Same drawer